The honest answer; IKEA is usually cheaper on basics and storage, Wayfair can be cheaper on mid-range pieces when there’s a sale, and the cheapest cart of all is a mix of both. Whichever store you’d have picked by default, splitting your list saves real money.
To show why, here’s a side-by-side of comparable pieces from each retailer, using representative 2026 prices. Treat these as ballpark figures — Wayfair in particular runs constant flash sales, so the exact number the day you shop will differ. Check current prices before you buy.
The Cart Breakdown Piece By Piece
Here’s how comparable items line up across both stores:
| Item | IKEA | Wayfair (varies by brand/sale) | Usually cheaper |
|---|---|---|---|
| 3-seat sofa | KIVIK ~$599 | Andover Mills ~$489–$699 | Wayfair on sale, else close |
| Coffee table | LACK ~$30 | Mercury Row ~$89–$149 | IKEA |
| TV stand | BESTÅ ~$85–$250 | Zipcode Design ~$129–$279 | IKEA (modular) |
| Accent chair | POÄNG ~$129 | AllModern ~$249–$399 | IKEA |
| Queen bed frame | MALM ~$199 | Trent Austin ~$189–$349 | Close / IKEA on durability |
| 6-drawer dresser | MALM ~$179 | Andover Mills ~$229–$399 | IKEA |
| Open shelving | KALLAX ~$90 | (varies widely) | IKEA |
The pattern is hard to miss. On the small, functional, flat-pack basics — coffee tables, shelving, dressers, accent chairs — IKEA’s in-house pricing is tough to beat. On the bigger statement pieces like sofas, Wayfair’s sales can undercut IKEA, but only when a sale is actually running.
Why IKEA Wins on Basics
IKEA makes its own products at scale and sells them the same price everywhere, all year. There’s no middleman markup, and staples like the LACK table, KALLAX shelving, and POÄNG chair have stayed cheap for years precisely because they’re high-volume, no-frills designs. If your list is mostly storage, small tables, and simple seating, an all-IKEA cart is almost always the lowest sticker price.
The other quiet saving is predictability. You know the KALLAX costs what it costs, so you can plan a whole studio furnishing budget down to the dollar without waiting for a sale.
Why Wayfair Wins on the Right Day
Wayfair is a marketplace with the broadest price spectrum of any furniture retailer — you can find something as cheap as IKEA or as expensive as a high-end showroom. Its edge is the flash sale: discounts of 40–70% on mid-range furniture run frequently, and when a sofa or dining set you want lands in one, Wayfair can genuinely beat IKEA on the same dimensions.
The catch is that the sale is doing the work, not the everyday price. Off-sale, Wayfair’s mid-range pieces often list above the IKEA equivalent. So the play is to know your IKEA baseline price, then only buy from Wayfair when a sale drops it below that line.
The Cheapest Cart is a Hybrid
If you’re furnishing a whole apartment, don’t be loyal to one store. The lowest-total-cost approach for a first apartment is to split the list by what each retailer does best:
- Storage, shelving, small tables, and basic seating → IKEA. Lowest everyday prices, no sale required.
- Sofas, dining sets, and statement pieces → Wayfair, during a sale. Watch the price, pounce when it drops.
- Small decor and accessories → wherever’s cheapest that week, often a third store like Amazon for speed.
Splitting a first-apartment list this way commonly saves 20–30% versus buying everything from a single retailer. It’s more work, but on a full apartment that’s real money.
Don’t Forget the After-Purchase Costs
Sticker price isn’t the whole story. Two things can flip which store is actually cheaper:
- Returns: IKEA’s return window is long and forgiving. Wayfair returns on furniture can carry restocking and pickup fees, so a “cheaper” Wayfair piece you end up sending back can cost more than the IKEA one you’d have kept.
- Assembly and delivery: IKEA is flat-pack — cheap to get home if you have a car, a pain if you don’t. Many Wayfair items ship to your door mostly assembled, which is worth something if you have no way to haul a carload of boxes up three flights.
Which is Cheaper?
For a first apartment built mostly from basics and storage, IKEA is the cheaper default. If your list leans toward a statement sofa or a dining set and you can wait for a sale, Wayfair can win on those pieces. And if you want the genuinely lowest total, buy the basics at IKEA and the big pieces at Wayfair on sale.
This piece is about price. If you’re weighing whether the cheaper option is also the better-built one, see our breakdown of IKEA vs Wayfair quality for the price and, for seating specifically, IKEA vs Wayfair sofas after a year of use. For the full picture across every category, start with our IKEA vs Wayfair guide for small apartments.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQs)
1. Is Wayfair or IKEA cheaper overall?
For everyday prices on basics and storage, IKEA is cheaper. Wayfair can be cheaper on mid-range and statement pieces when a flash sale is running, but often lists above IKEA off-sale. The cheapest total comes from splitting your list between both.
2. What’s cheaper at IKEA than Wayfair?
Coffee tables, open shelving, dressers, TV stands, and accent chairs are typically cheaper at IKEA thanks to its in-house, high-volume pricing. Staples like the LACK table and KALLAX shelving are hard to beat anywhere.
3. When is Wayfair cheaper than IKEA?
During Wayfair’s frequent flash sales (often 40–70% off), mid-range items like sofas and dining sets can drop below the comparable IKEA price. Know your IKEA baseline and buy from Wayfair only when a sale beats it.
4. Is it cheaper to buy everything from one store?
Usually not. For a full first apartment, buying basics and storage at IKEA and big pieces at Wayfair during sales commonly saves 20–30% versus shopping at a single retailer.
About The Author
